Fear, Force, Punishment & Corrections: Part 3, Force.

October 24, 2016

Why There’s No Such Thing as Force-Free Dog Training

Are You Using Using Force?

You’ve just come home from work. Your dog is happy to see you. You put the leash on and take him for a walk. You want to go to the bank, which is to your left, but your dog wants to go to the park, which is to the right. What do you do?

If you take him to the bank, you’re using force. Granted, it's a very mild form of force, but it’s force nevertheless.

Another example: you let your puppy out of her pen for some free time. You try to keep an eye on her but your attention wanders. And when you look back you see her chewing on some electrical cords. Do you let her continue chewing or do you pull her away from danger?

If you pull her away, you’re using force.

You’re teaching your dog to heel. Your “force-free” trainer recommends using a head harness. “It’s more humane than a collar,” she tells you. Yet every time your dog pulls forward, his head and neck automatically get pulled to one side or the other.

If you’re using a head harness, you’re using force. (And not in a nice way.)

All dog trainers and owners use physical force in some form or another. Those who say they don’t are either mistaken, misguided, or lying.

“One of the Biggest Advertising Gimmicks of All Time”

On her blog at DogStar Daily, positive trainer Nicole Silver writes, “All training incorporates an element of force.” She goes on to define force as “the denial of access. The leash, the muzzle, even the collar, the crate, the fence are all force tools.”

Sara Reusche, another blogger writes that the phrase force-free “is one of the biggest advertising gimmicks of all time.”

She goes on to explain, “Is it considered forceful to stand on a dog’s leash so that he has enough leash to comfortably sit, stand, or lie down, but not enough to jump up on a stranger? Is it forceful to use body blocks to keep my dog from lunging at a passing bike?”

Of course the answer is yes.

Reusche goes on to describe watching a friend’s dog happily run back to her owner, motivated by low-level shocks from an electronic collar. The dog seemed perfectly happy and not at all distressed.

She also once saw a well-known “positive” trainer give a demonstration of clicker training at a seminar. Yet, according to Rausche, the demonstration dog “was clearly uncomfortable with the amount of pressure placed on her by the trainer. The dog’s body was low and she was licking her lips and turning her head away.”

She goes on: “The force-free training movement would have you believe that the first trainer is evil because of her use of an e-collar, while the second trainer is good because she was using a clicker and treats. However, I bet if we asked the two dogs which was happier with [their] training … we’d get very different answers.”

Don’t get me wrong. I don’t use electronic collars: never have, never will. In my world lectricity is not a dog’s friend.

Internal and External Forces: The Natural Mechanisms for Learning

It seems to me that all learning takes place through the usually sudden release of feelings of tension, pressure, and stress.

If we look at one of the most fundamental principles of behavior—the stimulus/response chain—a stimulus is, by definition, something that applies some kind of energetic impact onto an organism. This is a universal process and includes everything from the strong and steady forces at work during cell division to the behaviors of a dog chasing a squirrel or the sexual tension felt by two young people deeply attracted to one another.

In each case the organism’s response is, on the most basic level, a means of finding a way to reduce or release feelings of internal tension, pressure, and stress. That’s why the dog is driven to chase the squirrel and why the potential lovers can’t stop thinking about each other.

Artificial Forms of Learning

When B. F. Skinner set out to form a scientific model of learning and behavior he made certain that his lab rats and pigeons were not only fasted to 2/3s their normal body weight but were also trapped inside boxes. unable to get out. Talk about tension, pressure, and stress! Skinner’s work also shows that all learning takes place through external and internal forces. The external force was confinement; the internal force was hunger.

Was Skinner’s model natural or artificial?

I would say it was mostly artificial.

Skinner’s thesis was that learning took place because of the associations his test subjects made between a) pressing or pecking a lever when a light came on b) and the subsequent food pellets dropped into their habitat.

A Feeling of Release

Yet what seemed unimportant and perhaps even unknowable to Skinner, was the simple fact that pressing the lever and eating the food pellets gave his rats and pigeons a feeling of release. Being in the box was stressful. Being hungry was stressful. So there’s no question that the sudden release of the food pellet also created a sudden release of internal tension, pressure and stress. Like a magician with a deck of cards, Skinner was forcing the animals to choose the behavioral card he’d already selected for them.

So whenever trainers talk about the use of force—and whether it’s right or wrong, necessary or unnecessary—they’re usually defining things within a very narrow, not to mention unrealistic, window. They’re also ignoring their own use of force, which happens on a regular basis (as with their recommendations of using a head harness instead of a collar).

Yes, things like hitting a dog, pushing a puppy’s tush down to teach him to sit, or forcing the dog over on his side in an alpha roll are improper uses of force. Granted these examples are not an integral part of the positive training methodology. And they’re certainly not any part of mine. But even in the make-believe world of +R, there’s no such thing as force-free dog training. The only question is whether said force is appropriate to the situation, and more importantly how your dog feels about it.

But the most important thing to remember is that learning doesn’t necessarily take place through associations between a stimulus (eg. a light flashing) and reward (the food pellet). It takes place through the sudden release of internal tension, pressure, and stress felt in the dog’s body, and how the dog finds ways to release those feelings.

The dog trained with an electronic collar was getting that feeling feeling of release. The demonstration dog at the +R seminar wasn’t.

Lee Charles Kelley

“Life Is an Adventure—Where Will Your Dog Take You?”

Join Me on Facebook!

Follow Me on Twitter!

Link Up With Me on Linkedin!

Featured Posts
Recent Posts


  • Facebook Social Icon
  • Twitter Social Icon
  • LinkedIn Social Icon
  • Black Facebook Icon
  • Instagram - Black Circle
  • Black Vimeo Icon

© 2016 by Lee Charles Kelley.